Empire Company Ltd. (EMP-A:CA)
Scotiabank lowered its 12 month target price on Empire Company Ltd, (the parent of grocery chains Sobeys, Safeway, FreshCo, Farm Boy, and Longo’s), to $58 from $63, citing mounting challenges that are likely to weigh on the company’s performance over the next two years. The downgrade to the stock’s valuation reflects concerns over intensifying competition within the Canadian grocery retail sector, as rival chains and discount retailers step up promotions and pricing strategies to win back price-sensitive shoppers in a high-inflation environment.
Empire, which has invested heavily in modernization, digital integration, and its discount banners, is facing pressure on margins as consumer spending shifts towards lower-cost alternatives. Competitors like Loblaw and Metro are aggressively pushing their discount formats (e.g., No Frills, Maxi, and Food Basics), further squeezing Empire’s growth prospects.
Scotiabank also highlighted the rising operating costs tied to supply chain inefficiencies, ongoing wage pressures, and continued investments in technology and e-commerce platforms. While Empire’s long-term strategy of expanding FreshCo in Western Canada and strengthening Farm Boy in Ontario has shown promise, execution risks remain elevated given the current economic backdrop.
The reduced price target suggests that investors should temper expectations for near-term upside, with growth likely to be muted until competitive pressures ease and consumer demand stabilizes. Analysts caution that the next 18–24 months could be defined by narrower margins, slower same-store sales growth, and the need for disciplined cost management.
Stock Forecast
Analysts maintain a consensus “Hold” rating on the stock, reflecting a cautious but not overly bearish stance. The average analyst 12 month target price is CAD $58.80 per share, suggesting modest potential upside from current trading levels. The consensus outlook points to Empire being fairly valued in the short term, with limited upside as it weathers a tough competitive landscape. Long-term opportunities remain if management can execute on cost-saving initiatives, grow its digital platform, and improve operational efficiency, but in the immediate horizon, analysts expect only moderate performance.
STA Research (StockTargetAdvisor.com) is a independent Investment Research company that specializes in stock forecasting and analysis with integrated AI, based on our platform stocktargetadvisor.com, EST 2007.
Empire’s challenge really highlights how competitive the grocery sector has become, especially with inflation pushing shoppers toward discount options. It’ll be interesting to see if their investments in FreshCo and Farm Boy can offset margin pressures in the long run, but in the short term, rising operating costs and aggressive moves from rivals like Loblaw seem hard to overcome. The next couple of quarters should give a clearer picture of whether their strategy is sustainable.